 |
Dominion News Releases
March 17, 2000
Dominion Bid for New York Nuclear Stations is Higher Than
Competing Offer
Richmond,Va.; – Dominion (NYSE: D), the nation’s top nuclear
operator, said today that its offer to acquire two New York Power Authority
nuclear stations provides $946 million in direct economic value to the authority
— 17 percent above a competing offer of $806 million by Entergy Corporation
(NYSE: ETR).
On March 10, the deadline for final offers, Dominion submitted
the bid to acquire NYPA’s Indian Point 3 and James A. FitzPatrick nuclear stations.
If speculative economic benefits of Dominion’s offer are
added, the offer’s total value to NYPA and New York consumers is $1.52 billion.
By contrast, if speculative economic benefits of Entergy’s offer are added,
the Entergy offer provides only $1.32 billion in direct and speculative value.
Included in each company’s estimate of speculative economic benefit is the establishment
of a regional office headquartered in New York, which Entergy’s release valued
at $300 million.
Last night, a subsidiary of Entergy issued a release asserting
that it has made a superior offer of $1.42 billion in both direct and speculative
economic benefits.
Thos. E. Capps, president and chief executive officer, said:
"For the record, I want to compare apples to apples.
If Entergy’s total value provides $1.42 billion in total benefits, Dominion’s
offer provides $1.52 billion. But it’s absolutely essential to note that Entergy’s
most recent news release mistakenly adds $100 million in phantom value."
Capps noted:
- The statement asserts that Entergy will provide an additional
$92 million as part of an initial obligation to begin funding future decommissioning
expenses — in addition to allowing NYPA to reduce its decomissioning
obligation by $50 million. In fact, the Entergy offer on record to fund decommissioning
expenses offers $92 million in lieu of a $50 million reduction.
- Further, Entergy’s actual commitment to provide only $92
million in decommissioning expenses is effective beginning only in 2008, cutting
by more than half the value of the commitment in today’s dollars.
- In addition, the statement claims that an offer by Entergy
to sell additional output at the FitzPatrick plant extends through 2004, when
their official offer of March 10 states a date of 2003. Thus, Entergy’s claim
of value is inflated by approximately $12 million.
By correcting for these discrepancies, Entergy’s offer provides
only $1.32 billion in direct and speculative value, or $200 million less than
Dominion’s offer.
Notwithstanding these discrepancies, Dominion’s offer provides
significantly higher value for three reasons:
- Its offer to pay $946 million for the physical facilities
and their fuel;
- An enhanced value sharing agreement, which would share
profits with NYPA should market power prices exceed projected levels. The
Dominion proposal would provide an additional $169 million in speculative
value to NYPA, compared to Entergy’s revised proposal to provide only $35
million in additional speculative value.
- Additional value sharing should Dominion acquire additional
nuclear facilities in New York totaling up to $100 million.
Capps said:
"We’re offering more money. We’re the better, safer
and more efficient nuclear operator and better home for NYPA employees. We’re
financially stronger with a better credit rating and stronger standing in the
financial community. We’re proposing a superior value sharing agreement. And
we have a large presence in and a commitment to growth in New York as a competitive
energy provider."
Capps added:
"Among points that clearly set Dominion above and apart
from Entergy or any other nuclear operating company are these:
- "Dominion’s two nuclear power stations have consistently
achieved the top ranking for performance excellence from the Institute of
Nuclear Power Operations (INPO). North Anna has had five consecutive top rankings
since 1991 and Surry four consecutive since 1993. Safety and superior performance
go hand-in-hand.
- "Our nuclear power stations are among the safest
in the country. Their average score for the last three periods of the Nuclear
Regulatory Commission’s Systematic Assessment of Licensee Performance (SALP)
reports was 1.22, with 1.0 being the best possible rating. Entergy’s was not
as good at 1.58. The Authority should expect nothing less from any bidder
than a singular focus on nuclear safety.
- "Our nuclear employees have been with the company
for an average of 16 years. We value experience and leadership throughout
our ranks, spot future leaders, and train them to maintain a high level of
accountability. Our units do not operate themselves: It takes dedicated employees
who are proud of their accomplishments.
- "Dominion is experienced in bringing other employees
into the family in ‘seamless’ fashion with regards to benefits and pensions.
Whether we have acquired businesses as far away as the United Kingdom and
South America or as nearby as Illinois and New York, we are deeply experienced
and mindful of the importance of swiftly addressing the basic concerns of
our newest employees – growth opportunities, compensation, benefits, insurance
and pension plans. We have met with many of the Authority’s employees at both
stations and at White Plains. We were extremely impressed with them."
The acquisition would be immediately accretive to earnings.
Dominion, headquartered in Richmond, Va., is the largest
fully-integrated natural gas and electric power provider in the U.S. The company
serves 4 million retail gas and electric customers in five states. It has 20,000
megawatts of electric generating capacity, with an additional 6,000 megawatts
currently under development. Dominion is also one of the largest independent
oil and natural gas exploration and production companies in North America, with
3 trillion cubic feet of reserves.
###
| |
|
|
| Media: |
Mark Lazenby; 804-819-2042 |
|
|
Hunter Applewhite; 804-819-2043 |
|
| Analysts: |
Tom Wohlfarth; 804-819-2150 |
|
|
Suzette Mata; 804-819-2154 |
|
|
 |